When planning international travel, one of the biggest factors to consider is that the carry-on fits within the size restrictions of major airlines. Bonus points if it also offers durability, functionality, and a solid warranty. Luckily, for Canadian travellers, we have found all of those things in these two bags. So, let’s compare the Briggs & Riley Baseline International Carry-On Spinner and the Tumi Alpha 3 International Expandable 4-Wheeled Carry-On.
Briggs & Riley Baseline International Carry-On Spinner
Size and Weight:
- Dimensions: 21" x 14" x 9"
- Weight: 8.9lbs
Pros:
- Durability: Made with ballistic nylon, it’s built to last through the rigors of extensive travel.
- Warranty: The standout feature is its lifetime warranty, which even covers airline damage. This provides peace of mind for frequent travelers.
- Design: Features such as the external handle system, which maximizes internal packing space, and the compression-expansion system, make packing more efficient.
- Customer Reviews: Users consistently praise the robust build and the practicality of the design. It is highly recommended for international travelers who value functionality and longevity.
Cons:
- Weight: Slightly heavier than some ultra-lightweight options, but the weight is justified by its durability.
- Cost: The premium price can be a barrier, but it is justified by the quality and comprehensive warranty.
Tumi Alpha 3 International Expandable 4-Wheeled Carry-Only
Size and Weight:
- Dimensions: 22" x 14" x 9"
- Weight: 10.4 lbs
Pros:
- Stylish Design: Known for its sleek and professional look, appealing especially to business travelers.
- Features: Includes a built-in USB port for charging devices, Tumi Tracer® system for lost luggage recovery, and multiple organizational pockets.
- Build Quality: Constructed from FXT ballistic nylon, offering excellent durability.
- User Feedback: Reviewers appreciate the style and functionality, along with tech-friendly features like the USB port and the secure TSA-friendly lock.
Cons:
- Weight: Heavier than the Briggs & Riley, which can be a concern for those who prioritize lightweight luggage.
- Warranty: Comes with a five-year warranty, which is less comprehensive compared to Briggs & Riley’s lifetime guarantee.
- Price: High cost with some users feeling it is more reflective of the brand prestige rather than functional benefits.
Canadian Traveler Considerations
Briggs & Riley:
- Positive Feedback: "The lifetime warranty makes it an easy choice for frequent travelers. I’ve had mine repaired twice without any hassle." (Luggage Pros)
- Design Appreciation: "Built like a tank and packs like a dream. The external handle design is brilliant for maximizing space." (One Mile At A Time)
Tumi:
- Positive Feedback: "Great for business travel. Looks professional and has held up well over multiple trips." (Nordstrom)
- Critical Points: "The Tumi Alpha 3 is stylish and loaded with features, but it’s a bit heavy. The USB port is handy, but the warranty isn’t as good as I’d like for the price." (Expert World Travel)
The Verdict :
You really can’t go wrong with either of these carry-ons. BUT, for travellers looking for a light(er)weight, high-quality bag with an excellent warranty, the Briggs & Riley Baseline International Carry-On Spinner is the recommended choice. Its slightly lighter weight, superior lifetime warranty, and practical design features make it the best option for those prioritizing functionality and long-term value.
However, if brand prestige, additional tech features, and a modern aesthetic are important, the Tumi Alpha 3 International Expandable 4-Wheeled Carry-On is still a solid choice despite its heavier weight and higher cost . This choice might be more suitable for business travelers who value the stylish design and additional features like the USB port and Tumi Tracer® system.
Have you travelled with either of these bags? Let us know your thoughts!